Home
Cigars
Pipe Smoke
Shisha
RYO
Chew & Snus
Nasal Snuff
Smoking Accessories
Lampe Berger
Dunhill
Reviews
Our Store
Contact Us
Resources
facebook
twitter
flickr
youtube
 
Royal Oak Store
1-250-744-2772
Monday - 10:00 - 6:00
Tues - Sat. 10:00 - 10:00
Sun - Closed
 

Downtown Victoria Store
1-250-385-2772
Mon - Sat 10:00 - 6:00
Sun - 12:00 - 5:00


Downtown Summer Hours
Mon - Wed 10:00 - 6:00
Thurs - Sat 10:00 - 8:00
Sun - 12:00 - 5:00
(In Effect: June to Sept.)

 
 
 
 
 

 

GOODFELLAS REVIEWS

 

We're very happy to begin sharing our personal reviews of cigars in 2018. Here's what we're smoking and our personal opinion on it. Enjoy!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Cody reviews the excellent mild cigar from CLE: CLE Connecticut Robusto

Owned by Christian Eiroa, he is the former president of his family’s brand Camacho cigars before it was acquired by Davidoff. The CLE stands for Christian’s full name. The CLE line offers many different blends at the moment, the most famous being the Corojo, the Connecticut, and Cuarenta.  These represent the core of his new venture that has grown a great amount in a short time. However, some of CLE’s sub cigar lines like Eiroa, Asylum and Insidious have been very successful and well received.

Prelight
The cigar wrapper is a nice light shade Ecuadorian Connecticut and uses Honduran filler and binder, making for a nice mild Honduran cigar. The Wrapper is light with veins and seams visible in the wrapper, but it is smooth and oily with a sheen. With just a bit of tug on the prelight draw, the cigar presents a nice wood spice on the palate which is different than your typical Connecticut cigar.

First Third
The cigar starts out very smooth with dashes of pepper and earth, slowly turning into a spicy cedar on the finish, but remains very mild on the palette.  The burn is good and does not veer off at all, with a great solid white ash as well.

Second Third
The cigar delivers more earth onto the palate and dies down on the pepper but still offers that nice spicy cedar on the finish but never makes the cigar feel any stronger.  The body is consistent and is not shifting.  Ash still strong and perfect burn line.

Final Third
The cigar has a upshift in the pepper and tones down the earth to a more toasted nut flavour, making for a very nice ending to the cigar.  The strength is still very mild and smooth. The finish is earthier than spicy and makes nubbing the cigar very easy to accomplish.

Final Thoughts
If you are new or simply prefer a mild cigar to try but are looking for something a little different than other Connecticut options, this cigar is definitely a great choice. It offers more than just that “Nutty and Creamy” profile that dominates the mild cigar market. It has a unique flavour and complexity but maintains itself as a very easy smoking cigar. Packed with amazing construction and good flavours, this is a hard mild cigar option to beat. This would be a great cigar for a beginner just getting into the hobby, or a cigar to start your day with a nice cup of coffee!

Reviewed by Cody Hall, staff member at Goodfellas. Available at our Downtown location.

Perla Del Mar Review

Cody reviews the brand new arrival to Goodfellas: Perla Del Mar Maduro

The Perla Del Mar Maduro is a nice dark and flavourful cigar, utilizing 100% Nicaraguan tobaccos produced by JC Newman. Sporting a dark Connecticut broadleaf wrapper to stand apart from its Connecticut shade brother. The cigar is slightly box-pressed, adding a nice aesthetic to the cigars appeal and the wrapper is uniform with minimal veins.

Prelight
The cigar exudes pleasant sweet cocoa scents and a slight hint of spice, with a touch of molasses. Cutting is effortless and the draw is perfect with only a bit of tug to it. Nice sweet flavours on the prelight draw, almost like milk chocolate.

First Third
After an easy light, I am greeted with a nice deep and rich earthy spice accompanied by a sweet leather and cedar on the palate. The aroma of the cigar is pleasant and robust, very woodsy. The texture of the smoke is creamy and smooth. Nice hint of red pepper sweetness on the finish and the burn is uniform.

Second Third
Flavours begin to get bolder and more rich, with the spice taking the forefront of the experience. A nice amount of black pepper flavours coat the tongue and levels back into a nice sweet and spicy cedar. Much of the same, but bolder like a deep dark coffee. Slight hint of mineral flavors on the finish.

Final Third
The cigar completely opens up, revealing all of its riches. Now taking the forefront is a deep rich earth almost like a dark espresso, with the pleasant cocoa flavors to accompany it. The finish is now deep in leather and very smooth with the spice.

Final Thoughts
Smoked down to the nub, this cigar is very pleasant and not too strong for the avid cigar enthusiast. The cigar is full bodied but not too much so, and is very relaxed on the spice but offers consistent cocoa flavours throughout. A nice creamy texture lasts the whole cigar making for an easy smoking experience for all. Overall, any lover of a maduro can get into this cigar and should be able to greatly enjoy it, especially if you love the original Perla Del Mar and are looking for something with noticeable more depth and boldness. A great cigar and very well constructed, as expected from JC Newman and their creations!

 

Reviewed by Cody Hall, staff member at Goodfellas. Available at our Downtown location. Reviewed May, 2017.

Alec Bradley Coyol

Sporting unique tobaccos from the Trojes region in Honduras and a double binder, including Nicaraguan tobacco as well, the Coyol is truly a very interesting cigar. Using tobacco exclusive to the Coyol farm in Honduras, a great blend was made for the eager cigar enthusiast and provides a new experience for those looking for a new taste to explore. Rich in oils and medium bodied this should be pleasant to most enthusiasts.

Prelight


The cigar is slim and wrapped delicately, with a slightly spotty wrapper indicating the tobacco is rich with oils. Very sweet earthy scents are all over the cigar, and the cigar is uniform with minimal veins. After cutting the cap and testing the draw it presents typical sweet cedar and earth flavors. Great draw with some tug though.

First Third

           
Upon lighting, the cigar produces a fantastic aroma that is sweet and slightly floral. Initial flavors are a sweet leather and a very light cedar. Finish is very earthy and settles on the palate, but sweet and rather pleasant.

Second Third


The cigar remains much of the same with the earth toning down and the spice ramping up. The flavors are meshing into a very nice sweet yet savory assortment of spices, and on the finish there is now a slight citrus sweetness reminiscent of mangoes or papaya.

Final Third


The final third of the cigar becomes full and bold. Spice is abundant and leather coat the palate. The spice is similar to cracked white pepper and very savory. The citrus on the finish of the second third is now present in the body of the cigar itself and makes for an interesting experience, makes for a tangy sweet flavor which is very unique.

Final Thoughts

           
Having enjoyed the cigar to the bitter end, this cigar is very unique with its flavors and stands out from Alec Bradley’s other lines. The citrus flavors that bring out a fruitiness are truly what set this cigar apart aside from its attractive wrapper and unique tobaccos. The cigar stayed even with the burn the whole time and the ash never fell off before desired, very well constructed. This cigar is definitely for those looking for something different than more typical and common flavours. Very delicious and medium to full bodied, which should be able to be enjoyed by any bold enthusiast looking for something new to puff on!

Reviewed by Cody Hall, staff member at Goodfellas. Available at Royal Oak & Downtown. Reviewed April 7th, 2017

-----------------------------------------------------------------------